Readers who have some prior knowledge of king and x will find it especially rewarding clayborne carson on king and alex haley on malcolm are recommended. This is a fine book, and as good a comparisoncontrast of martin luther king jr. The catholicism of martin luthers time was hyperfocused on the value of works, but luther found that. Preserved smiths the life and letters of martin luther on page 269. If you are unfamiliar with the book of concord, please consult the helpful explanations available in the left hand column under the introductions section. Blog post john macarthur on the legacy of martin luther. What was martin luthers opinion of the book of james answers. Jul 09, 2009 early in his work as bible lecturer and translator luther expressed doubt as to whether james, hebrews, and revelation are truly apostolic part of the inspired new testament. I just opened my bible and right after hebrews is james. Paul and all the rest of scripture in ascribing justification to works 2. I understand the he discarded james because of the problematic verse james 2. There are four commonly espoused views concerning authorship and dating of the epistle of james. The calling is the first book in a series that stars no nonsense deputy inspector john luther. Iakobos, the epistle of james, or simply james, is one of the 21 epistles didactic letters in the new testament the author identifies himself as james, a servant of god and of the lord jesus christ who is writing to the twelve tribes scattered abroad.
Thats where the foundation of jamess call to action is plainest. There are three things about luther and james that might interest us today. Did martin luther really want james taken out of zondervan. James was rejected by the ancients, i praise it and consider it a good book, because it sets up no doctrines of men but vigorously promulgates the law of god. Luther and the epistle of straw the calvinist international.
Jun, 20 luther famously referred to the book of james as an epistle of straw, purportedly because of its lackluster portrayal of the gospel and the ease with which it might be used to foster doctrines of worksrighteousness. Luther s biggest issue with the book of james was that it appeared to contradict paul, and it seemed to oppose the doctrine of justification by faith alone, which was a central tenet of the protestant movement. If im not mistaken, martin luther discarded the book of james and revelation in his initial version of the bible. And he never says james isnt worth reading he just didnt think it was scripture. Sep 09, 2015 the example of the book of esther is merely one example of many biblical books that martin luther felt free to judge wholly based on his subjective opinion. Scholars have compared james speech and letter of acts 15. Luther made an attempt to remove the books of hebrews, james, jude and revelation from the canon notably, he perceived them to go against certain protestant doctrines such as sola gratia and sola fide citation needed but his followers did not generally accept luther s personal judgment in this matter. Luther, according to the holman bible dictionary, disciples study bible and other references, had the greatest difficulty with what james wrote about faith and works in the second chapter of his book.
Protestant reformer martin luther cogwriter although protestants like to think positively about martin luther because of his supposed belief in sola scriptura the bible alone, the truth is that martin luther changed parts of the bible and discounted the value of many books. The following is the translation from luthers works, vol. There is no way to settle the issue for certain, but most scholars agree that james the lords brother is most likely to have been the author of the book of james. Luther says he cannot include him among the chief books, though i would not thereby prevent anyone from including or extolling him as he pleases, for there are otherwise many good sayings in him. We must keep the commandments and have faith in god.
Apr 02, 2014 the great protestant reformer, martin luther, infamously referred to the book of james as an epistle of straw in his preface to the german new testament. Why is the book of james not found on the protestant bible. Feb 07, 2008 i am a vineyard church pastor which some would consider protestant but sort of on the charismatic side of it. If youve ever entered into a discussion on the canon of scripture, the issue of luthers view inevitably comes up. Luthers treatment of the disputed books ageecreative. The second comments in green made by luther were replaced by other comments that are in maroon in the editions after 1530. I have the niv, the open, new king james and king james versions of the bible and all have the book of james in it. We thought it appropriate to share johns words with you here, both to coincide. Jul 09, 2009 luther s preface to james and jude according to luther. Five hundred years ago, luther reclaimed the gospel from the medieval church, but did he leave the book of james behind. Martin luther and the book of james shameless popery. Last fall, john macarthur contributed a foreword to r.
James has therefore been vindicated by the truth of the word of god. Did martin luther really want james taken out of the bible. Welcome to the book of concords home on the internet. Foster, there is little consensus as to the genre, structure, dating, and authorship of the book of james. Its been suggested that luther wasnt arguing that james shouldnt be in the bible, just that it wasnt as useful as other books. It is curious that in the sermon, luther refers to james as the apostle, and it is also interesting that he does discuss the gospel and the resurrection. What part of the poem quietness where the persona is. Of course, martin luther was very much aware that this verse was in the book of james. What is less well known or talked about, is that luther also praised the book of james in the same preface. First, christians overwhelmingly believe the book ought to be in the bible. In fact, luther referred to the book of james as an epistle of straw and sought unsuccessfully to have the entire book. He viewed it as teaching salvation by works rather than justification by. Luther was reading romans, where paul makes it very clear that its not through the works of the law that any man is justified and that we are justified by faith and only through faith. The catholicism of martin luther s time was hyperfocused on the value of works, but luther found that.
James earl ray and the assassination of martin luther king, jr. Luthers biggest issue with the book of james was that it appeared to contradict paul, and it seemed to oppose the doctrine of justification by faith alone, which was a central tenet of the protestant movement. Jan 02, 2020 the book of james is directed to jewish christians scattered among all the nations james 1. And the key word to come to terms with is word, which appears four times in the passage verses 18, 21, 22, and 23. Luthers comment about james being an epistle of straw, as compared to the theological signifiance of pauls writings, is his most well known comment on the book. The story opens when one of luther s friends on the police department gets roughed up by two thugs hired by a man who is trying to get a senior citizen to sell his home so the criminal can develop the land. The gospel of james open letter to martin luther close. Martin luther changed andor discounted 18 books of the bible.
Lutheran theologians like to make a distinction between the books of the new testament which were unanimously received as canonical in the early church the socalled homologoumena or undisputed books and the books which were disputed by some the antilegomena. Now in green are some comments that luther originally made that were in editions of his bible prior to 1530. Mar 14, 2018 it would seem that that text would blow luther out of the water forever. Luthers treatment of the disputed books of the new testament. Martin luther, who detested this letter and called it the epistle of straw, failed to recognize that jamess teaching on works complementednot contradictedpauls teaching on faith. Some of the key parts from verses 14 to 26 which martin luther disagreed with are the following. But knowing that such a great scholar questioned it opens a fascinating window on to how we came to have. Martin luthers hostility to the book of james is wellknown, and ive mentioned it in other contexts, but i wanted to consider today the implications for the lutheran view of justification, at the heart of the reformation and of modern catholicprotestant disputes. Did martin luther deny the canonicity of the book of esther. Why did martin luther discard the book of revelation. Nestingen has taught church history at luther seminary in st. He is a nationally recognized luther scholar as well as a popular speaker and lecturer.
Study james using martin luthers bible commentary to better understand scripture with full outline and verse meaning. Yes, luther had a problem with the book of james, calling it a right strawy epistle, having no true evangelical character. Martin luther, founder of the protestant reformation, referred to the book of james as an epistle of straw. Heres the full context of luthers evaluation from his preface to the new testament. Reston does not ignore luther s dark side, but he doesnt follow the sensationalist trend of many recent biographers. He called james a straw epistle because he thought james was opposing paul on justification through faith alone. This scripture must have posed quite a problem for martin luther. Mar 19, 2012 what was martin luther s opinion of the book of james. Nov 12, 2008 yes, luther had a problem with the book of james, calling it a right strawy epistle, having no true evangelical character. Jan, 2016 at times it does appear luther accepted james as an apostle and his book as canonical.
Martin luther s hostility to the book of james is wellknown, and ive mentioned it in other contexts, but i wanted to consider today the implications for the lutheran view of justification, at the heart of the reformation and of modern catholicprotestant disputes. Chasing down the luther quotes about james taylor marshall. Apr 03, 2007 comments off on six points on luthers epistle of straw six points on luthers epistle of straw almost five hundred years after the fact, roman catholics still scrutinize martin luther. Sproul and stephen nicholss book, the legacy of luther. Six points on luthers epistle of straw alpha and omega. What is comparison and contrast of miss phathupats and yeyeng. I do not give commentary, but i think that luther speaks for himself.
Luther detractors tend to focus on his statements asserting a contradiction between james and paul. Nestingen is the author of numerous books, including martin luther. Comments off on six points on luther s epistle of straw six points on luther s epistle of straw almost five hundred years after the fact, roman catholics still scrutinize martin luther. There are 40 phone book listings for people that are named luther james. A life 2003 and sources and contexts of the book of concord coeditor, 2001.
He does not consider james scripture, even if the book was in his bible. Many have asked for the reference for luthers quote, which states that st paul and st james stand in contradiction with one another on the doctrine of justification. Finding jesus in the book of james banner of truth usa. He viewed it as teaching salvation by works rather than justification by faith. The most popular passage comes from his preface to the book of james. The epistle of james is no epistle of straw, but instead it advocates building with gold on the foundation of christ and faith. However, these books are ordered last in the germanlanguage luther bible to this day. Luther s biggest issue with the book of james was that it appeared to contradict paul, and it seemed to oppose the doctrine of justification by faith alone, which was a central tenet of the. In fact, luther referred to the book of james as an epistle of straw and sought unsuccessfully to have the.
1361 1155 12 1340 298 1209 303 268 801 1566 1044 661 48 779 947 1004 200 1100 921 1264 1095 22 710 754 241 869 808 765 1044 1207 716 616 1469 238 56 26 586